A Charter Without Westminster: What English Pupils Should Ask For Now
Photo: Vyacheslav Argenberg, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Constitutional arguments about the UK's territorial constitution rarely reach the school gate. They should, because the difference between a right and a promise is felt most acutely by a fourteen-year-old asking why nobody had to listen to her.
Three settlements, one island
Scotland has incorporated the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child into Scots law through the UNCRC (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act, in force since 2024, albeit in a narrower form than originally drafted after the UK Supreme Court found parts of the Bill beyond the Scottish Parliament's competence. Whatever its limits, the Act created something England lacks: a legal frame within which a child's participation is not a courtesy but a requirement of public decision-making.
Wales took a different road. Its children's rights approach, rooted in a ministerial duty to have regard to the Convention, sits alongside a long-standing expectation that schools have council structures and that inspection takes pupil wellbeing seriously. The machinery is quieter than Scotland's, but it is machinery.
England has neither. Participation here rests on a patchwork: the citizenship curriculum, inspection expectations around personal development, the duty to consult on some policies, and the willingness of individual leaders. That patchwork is not worthless. It is simply not a right. A school can dismantle its council in September and no regulator is obliged to notice.
What the comparison actually teaches
The temptation is to conclude that English pupils should campaign for incorporation and wait a decade. That would be a mistake, for two reasons.
First, incorporation in Scotland did not settle the argument; it moved it. Rights framed in statute are still interpreted by adults with budgets. Second, and more usefully, the comparison shows what a school-level settlement would need to contain if it were to mean anything. The gap between a good council and a rights-respecting school is not a gap in enthusiasm. It is a gap in obligations, timescales and consequences.
The case for a school charter
A charter adopted by a governing body is not law. It can be withdrawn. But it does three things that a mission statement cannot. It converts vague goodwill into dated commitments. It creates a document against which pupils, parents and governors can measure the school. And it gives the headteacher something to point at when a proposal is inconvenient.
Critics will say this is voluntarism dressed as reform, and that the schools most in need will adopt it last. That is fair, and it is an argument for national entitlement, not against local progress. A charter is a staging post, not a destination.
Ten commitments a school could adopt this year
- A written right to be heard in decisions that affect pupils, named in the behaviour, admissions, uniform and curriculum policies.
- Reasons in writing when a decision goes against the views expressed by pupils — no silence, no “senior leadership considered feedback”.
- A published participation policy, reviewed annually and available to parents.
- Timetabled time, not extracted from a tutor's goodwill: a protected slot each week for council work.
- A response deadline, so that every consultation produces an answer within twenty school days.
- Minority safeguards, so that a majority vote does not extinguish the concerns of a small group — including pupils with SEND, carers and those in alternative provision.
- Accessible formats and translations, because a right to participate is meaningless if the paperwork is unreadable.
- A route of complaint that does not require a pupil to raise a grievance with the person they are complaining about.
- A standing governor item: an annual rights and participation report to the governing body, minuted.
- Training for adults and children alike, so that staff understand what participation is not — a survey, a focus group, a photo opportunity.
The English question
There is a respectable English argument for acting before Westminster does. Schools already hold duties under the Equality Act, the SEND Code of Practice and exclusions law that pupils rarely see explained in language they can use. A charter that gathers those duties into something a twelve-year-old could understand would be a modest but real act of constitutional education.
Scotland's Act did not make children equal. It made the argument unavoidable. English headteachers and governors can make the same argument in their own buildings now, and the first version could reasonably be drafted by the pupils it is meant to protect.